Moments that made a difference
The bloodiest battle in the Civil War could have had a different outcome
Image: Unseen Histories
What key moments made America the country it is today? The first to come to mind include the signing of the Declaration of Independence and the Emancipation Proclamation, and the Allies' Victory in World War II. But what if other events had transpired differently? What if a battle had ended with the victors losing and vice versa? Or if a protest had never happened? Here are ten pivotal what-if moments in our history.
1
The Boston Tea Party (1773)
The political unrest that eventually led to the American Revolutionary War was brewing well before the Boston Tea Party of 1773, but things might have gone a different way had this event not happened. The destruction of the East India Company’s tea by the Sons of Liberty as a protest against taxation was seen as a direct act of defiance by the British Parliament , who retaliated by closing the Boston Port, intervening in the Massachusetts colonial government, and stationing troops in private residences. This was seen as an act of war by the colonists, and it accelerated the gathering of the First Continental Congress and the start of the American Revolution.
2
The Crossing of the Delaware (1776)
By December 1776, the Continental Army was on the brink of defeat after a series of losses. The soldiers’ morale was low, and most enlistments were set to expire by the new year. The British had decided to hunker down for the winter season, instead of chasing the colonists, and General George Washington knew he had to act fast. On the night of December 25th, he led 2,400 across the icy Delaware River in the midst of a blizzard, hoping to catch the British forces garrisoned at Trenton by surprise. The attack was successful, and it was the first of a series of victories that uplifted the revolutionaries’ morale and changed the course of the war.
3
The Whiskey Rebellion (1791)
In 1791, the newly formed American government levied its first federal tax on whiskey, with the intention of using the revenue to pay war debts. However, this was met with strong resistance, protests, and even armed insurrection in the state of Pennsylvania. The peaceful suppression of the rebellion not only prevented further conflicts but also cemented the authority of the federal government over the states in matters of taxation. The role of the army led by Washington himself was crucial in the creation of a standing army—strongly opposed by many founding fathers—and it was the origin of the American military as one of the world's strongest.
4
The Bill of Rights (1791)
The original U.S. Constitution was met with strong opposition by many states, who saw it as infringing on individual rights and liberties, and as a possible source of government tyranny. A Bill of Rights, establishing and securing fundamental freedoms, was drafted and added as a condition for the ratification of the document. While this compromise was crucial for establishing the bases of the American nation, it also put into practice the mechanism for amending the Constitution, codified in Article V, and set the precedent that the supreme law of the land could evolve with the nation.
5
The Louisiana Purchase (1803)
Thomas Jefferson’s purchase of Louisiana from the French in 1803 was much more than a simple territorial acquisition. The 828,000 square miles territory, purchased for roughly 15 million dollars, doubled the size of America, now expanding its initial borders from the Mississippi to the Rocky Mountains. By securing the Mississippi River and the port of New Orleans, the U.S. expanded its agricultural economy and gained access to vast natural resources , while the control over a former French territory diminished the influence of European powers—mainly, the rising Napoleon Bonaparte— in North America. The soon-to-follow Westward expansion would add 13 new states to the Union.
6
The Battle of San Jacinto (1836)
Given its significance in Texan and American history, it is easy to forget that the 1836 Battle of San Jacinto lasted a mere 18 minutes. After the victory of the Mexican army at the Alamo and the massacre of war prisoners in Goliad, Texan morale was low, and the quest for Texas’ independence was nearly ended. Pursuing the remnants of the army led by Sam Houston, Mexican scouts incorrectly reported the route taken by the Texans, which allowed Houston to evade the enemy. After blocking the escape route and while the Mexican soldiers were taking a nap, 900 Texan soldiers attacked by surprise, killing more than half of the Mexican forces (around 1,300 men) and capturing the rest.
7
The Battle of Antietam (1862)
Widely considered to be the bloodiest battle of the American Civil War, with a tally of 22,726 casualties between dead, wounded, and missing people, the 1862 Battle of Antietam ultimately tipped the balance in the Union’s favor. But did you know that the casualties could have been far less? As the Union Army of the Potomac was moving to intercept the Confederate forces of General Lee, two Union soldiers came across a copy of Lee’s battle plans, detailing his intention of dividing the troops , which would allow the Union forces to isolate and defeat the Confederate army. However, Union General McClellan waited 18 hours before deciding to attack, which gave Lee the time to mount a strong defense in Antietam.
8
The New Deal (1932)
Burdened by the consequences of the Great Depression, Americans overwhelmingly supported the election of Franklin D. Roosevelt as president in 1932. Roosevelt’s main campaign promise, the New Deal, involved a series of economic, social, and political reforms to combat America’s economic crisis and restore the country’s trust in the government. The reforms weren’t entirely successful in ending the Great Depression —it only fully ended with the industrial mobilization for World War II— but they were key to ensuring that America would not suffer such a crisis again by establishing structural changes, relief programs, social security, and safety nets, regulating financial institutions, and ultimately showing American citizens that the government was working to help them.
9
The Cuban Missile Crisis (1962)
There were several moments during the Cold War Era (1947-1991) when the world thought a nuclear war was imminent, but none as close to it as the Cuban Missile Crisis. In October 1962, the Soviet government deployed nuclear missiles in Cuba as a response to similar deployments made by the U.S. in the UK, Italy, and Turkey. A 13-day crisis ensued, with President Kennedy ordering a naval blockade in Cuba, while his advisors pushed for an air strike and an all-out invasion. While the conflict ended peacefully, the nuclear war had been closer than most imagined: a U.S. Navy ship in the blockade had dropped signaling charges to deter a Soviet submarine, not knowing the submarine carried a nuclear torpedo. The Soviet captain assumed war had started and prepared to attack the ship, but he had to wait for confirmation. Luckily, the attack never happened, and a nuclear war was avoided.
10
The March on Washington (1963)
In 1963, at the height of the civil rights movement, social tensions were at an all-time high. Violent confrontations had happened in marches across the country, usually as a result of attacks on peaceful protesters. Still, these incidents had fueled the narrative of Civil Rights activists as violent and dangerous. As President Kennedy announced his intention to push for civil rights legislation, several organizations and leaders came together to organize the ‘March on Washington for Jobs and Freedom’. The march took place on August 28, 1963, and it's considered to have been one of the largest human rights rallies in American history, with an attendance of around 250,000 people. Besides landmark moments—such as MLK’s "I have a dream" speech— the march was crucial in showing peaceful protest and in pressuring the government to advance in what would later become the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and Voting Rights Act of 1965.
